Nothing to Lose But Your Time

Okay, I know you can’t expect too much of junk fiction. All you’re asking for is some lurid, maybe prurient, hopefully violent escapist time-killing. Anything beyond that is actually a bit suspect. Characterization? Plausibility? Well-drawn settings? Well, okay, if unavoidable, but let’s not strain ourselves.

Only two things are required, O Junk Novel. First, don’t be dull. I mean, kill time, yes, but don’t let me hear it groaning and pleading. Do your job mercifully. Second, know what you are: junk. Don’t put on airs and start preaching to me about your author’s hobby horses. Take warning from what a bore Heinlein became and Grisham is becoming.

First Harry Bosch. Now, Jack Reacher.Alas, one of my favorite junk tuff-guy writers, Lee Child, whose dozen previous thrillers had led me to expect snappy action unimpeded by socially redeeming values, has decided he actually has something to say.

I eagerly snatched up Nothing to Lose, his latest “Jack Reacher” bash-em and trash-em potboiler from the New Book display at the library, confident that it would deliver yet another update of Popeye vs. Bluto, only to discover that Mr. Lee had turned his lunk-hero into a pulpiteer on the evils of War (but only after 1945), Christians, American Army Men, and Big Business.

Aw, jeez, what a disappointment. It’s as though Mike Hammer started spouting off about global warming. Glad I didn’t actually plunk down dollars for this one.

Hope Mitch Rapp doesn't go Green.

Advertisements

2 responses to “Nothing to Lose But Your Time

  1. Looks like the title for my next blog post is already taken. Anyway … I agree about this book. So disappointing.

  2. Yeah, sad, ain’t it? The thing is, I wouldn’t have minded if Child had been Bolshy from the get-go like LeCarre, whose stuff I like, or if he had been a Rah-Rah Righty like Tom Clancy, who wrote one or two good’uns. But I enjoyed Jack Reacher’s almost nihilistic libertarianism. It defined the character; made for good escapism. It was reasonable to expect more of the same. This latest Reacher yarn feels like bait-and-switch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s